Home | Forums | Cool Case Gallery |Archive | Reviews | Articles | Guides | Links | VH Gear | Contests | Downloads | Contact
 

 
 
  NZXT Cryo S Notebook Cooler Review  
 
 
  XPad Slim Laptop Cooler Review  
 
 
  Glacialtech X-Wing Notebook Cooler Review  
 
 
  Thermaltake V9 Black Edition Case Review  
 
 
  Sparkle GTS250 Graphics Card Review  
 
 
  Noctua NH-U12P SE1366 Heatsink Review  
 
 
  GMC R-4 Bulldozer Case Review  
 
 
  OCZ 8GB Throttle eSATA/USB Drive Review  
 
 
  Supermicro SuperServer 5035L-IB Review  
 
 
  ASRock X58 SuperComputer Motherboard Review  
 
 
  VIZO Mini Ninja & Ninja HS Notebook Coolers Review  
 
 


 EK Water Blocks
 PC Water Cooling
 Quiet Cooling Fans
  Prolimatech Megahalems CPU Cooler
 Thermolab Baram CPU Cooler
 Arctic Cooling GTX 280
 Arctic Cooling 4870X2
 
CPU Coolers, Case Fans, Quiet Cooling, and Water Cooling

Get prices for...

 
 
Top Products

Motherboards
Intel | Abit
Gigabyte | Asus
Epox | Iwill
MSI | Shuttle
Tyan | Soyo
ECS | ASRock

Processors
AMD | Intel
Compaq

Cases
Antec | Lian-Li
Thermaltake
SilverStone
Coolermaster
ATX | BTX

Graphic Cards
ATI | nVidia

Memory
DDR | DDR2
Corsair | Crucial
OCZ | Patriot

Sound Cards
Creative Labs
Turtle Beach

Hard Drives
Seagate | Hitachi
Western Digital | Maxtor

Monitors
Viewsonic | Dell
Samsung | Apple

CD & DVD Burners
Plextor | Lite On
Sony | LG

 
 

 
Best viewed @ 1024 x 768 and higher

iStarUSA HDD Docking Station + HDD Reader Review
Date Published:
09-22-2008
Written By:
Tulatin
Edited By:
Diceman
Provided By:
iStarUSA
Where to Buy:
iStarUSA
Discuss Article:
VH Forum link
Pages: 1

Introduction:


Doesn't your data mean the world to you?

   Sometimes, those little details about computers are overlooked. Even among most enthusiasts, the interest is on the beef of a system - who you went with for a graphics card, what processor is there installed, which hard drives are you using, but when was the last time somebody asked you where those Serial ATA Cables came from, or inquired about who made that extra long DVI cord traveling to your screen - or in the scope of this review, who makes that USB device sitting on your desk that all your drives drop into.

It's this unfortunate niche that companies like iStarUSA fall into - they tend to be relied on when a certain cable has to be found on your local computer store's wall of them, but when it comes to flagship products, there's often so very little to be found. In that respect, today's review simply re-enforces the notion of companies such as this as merely logistics support to a burgeoning industry, yet, without them, certain things might not be possible. Things like what, you may ask? Years ago, I toyed with the idea of dual booting, on different hard drives in order to preserve my precious data in the event that I'd have to format, and partition the drive. Though concerns like this have largely passed on in the modern day, and dual booting is a thing of the past, the market for hot swappable hard drives, as well as easy to use, external data recovery devices has not.

In today's market, the "big idea" behind having multiple hard drive comes with a certain niche attached - convenience, security, or cost. Naturally, the convenience of being able to quickly replace a dead drive and return the array to working order, the security of being able to take the data with you, or the cost of effectively having multiple computer systems, with only the hard drive being changed. Call this last notion bygone if you will, but some of the people  I spent my past college days with followed these ideas to a T. Take for example, one of my classmates - outside of the classroom, he designed and maintained databases. In that respect, having two hard drives, with the interest of always having a working machine, and avoiding the inevitable debacle, when a classroom coding experiment goes horribly wrong. In that spirit, these two products received today - the T5-SS Hard Drive Reader and xAGE-N99-SAU/US HDD Docking Station will be viewed as a complete solution - or what you can utilize to have the freedom of two systems, but maintain the data portability of having a partitioned drive. Let's start simple, with the T5-SS.

The T5F-SS Hard Drive Reader:

Okay,  before the actual unboxing and dissection of this product begins, it's time for everyone's favorite formality, the features and specifications!

Features:

  • Screwless and Trayless Design for fast HDD mounting

  • Anti-vibration Design

  • Support SAS and SATA I/II Hard Drive

  • Key Lock Prevents Theft or Removal During Operation

  • Fit for Standard 5.25" Drive Bay

  • Best Air Ventilation with 1 x 40mm Fan

Specifications:

Model Number T5F-SS
RoHS Compliance Version Yes
Standard Drive Bays 5.25" Drive: 1

 

Cooling Fan 1x40mm
Interface SAS / SATA I/II
Connectors 2 x SATA
4 Pin Power Connector
Materials Frame: Metal
Front Panel: Plastic
LED Display HDD Activity
Security Key Lock
Certification TUV, CSA, CUL/ UL, CE
Packaging Information Mobile Rack, Manual, Keys, and Screws
Dimensions (W x H x D) 146 x 40 x 190 mm

Okay, with that finally out of the way, it's time for the second part of the first part of today's show; a series of classifications which I promise to not drag out again due to it's lovely complexity. Coming in a very nondescript box, the T5F-SS says all that it needs to without splashing out, and relying on cool graphics, or elaborate designs to sell the product; since in reality, this is an item which more serious consumers would be looking for, something that has a very specific purpose. Packaged securely inside this slightly sleeved cardboard box is the external rack that's come to be the first star of the show.


What an unassuming box
 

Well packed reader,
 accessories

The unpacked reader
 

The rather serious and conservative design of this unit is likely due thanks to two factors - one is the fact that it's intended for business and industrial environments, and two, that technology has evolved enough to simplify the process. Due in part to the similarity of the SATA and SAS connectors, as well as the (relative) durability of them, and the hot-swappable nature of the drives, the need for an HDD tray, sporting a bulky centrios plug at the back - as was in past - has now passed; as consumers are no longer beset with the worry of bending the pins of their precious drives.


Finger ready latch

Connectors, and Cooling

Hatch Open

Inside that hanger doorway

Combine this with a bit of clever engineering - which partially ejects the drive when the "door" is swung all the way open, as well as pushing it into place when it is closed, and a disk swap can probably be done in the span of 10 seconds - meaning that if the IT personnel are kept strung on enough caffeine, the deaths of hard drives may past unnoticed. That said, there are a few concerns with it all. First is the hinge of the door, which though cast in metal, may eventually work free of the plastic housing surrounding it. Secondly, is the questionable effectiveness of a whiny 40mm fan to cool the drive; while most disks puttering along at 7200 RPM will be fine, I can't help but wonder how hot 15,000 RPM SAS drives will get. Finally, the incompatibility of this unit with thinner drives puts a bit of a stop in the ideal of universally replaceable parts - though those thinner drives are a minority in market, to say the least.


Scoot your drives in

Drive Installed

In it's natural home

With that unit out of the way (and summary performance testing being pointless, as the drives won't be limited by something like a half inch of copper wire that their data has to travel through, it's time to continue on to the second part of this review - the xAGE unit - a product which files into a vein populated by the likes of Thermaltake, Silverstone, and even Vantec as of late - that's right, it's time to see what this take of the slot in hard drive reader looks like!

The xAGE-N99-SAU/US HDD Docking Station:

Right, so - again before the actual overview of this product starts, it's time for the Features and Specifications, of a product who's name I shan't list due to it being a mouthful (we'll just call it the xAGE from now on).

Features:

  • RoHS Compliance

  • Supports 2.5" & 3.5" SATA Hard Drives up to 1TB

  • Hot-Swap Capable

  • Power & HDD Activity LEDs

  • Plug and Play

  • Dual Data Transfer Connectors

  • Supports eSATA Transfer Speed up to 3Gbps

  • Supports USB 2.0 Transfer Speed up to 480Mbps

  • Windows, Mac, and Linux Compatible

Specifications:

Model Number                 xAGE-N99-SAU
RoHS Compliance Version Yes
Dimensions (W x H x D) 85 x 150 x 80 mm
HDD Interface 2.5"/3.5" SATA I/II
Host Interface USB2.0/eSATA
LED Display Power On/HDD Access
Material Plastic (ABS)
Color Black
Power Adapter 100-240V/AC to DC 12V 2.0A
Packaging Information Docking Station, eSATA Cable, USB Cable, HDD Cover(optional), and Power Adapter

Before taking a look at the package for this unit, I feel it would be appropriate to preface this unit with a general look at the types of user who would be taking advantage of it. First and foremost, this isn't the sort of product for everyone - even with the optional HDD covers installed, your drives are easily removeable by friend or foe, and largely exposed to the elements. Should the unit be victim to the flick of a wrist with a drive installed, it may simply turn into a projectile launcher. After saying that, I can safely say that this is a wonderful evolution on those 3-in-1 cables that came out a few years back, featuring IDE, 44-pin-Laptop-IDE-with-Power, and SATA. While the flexibility for a certain, ancient pin based interface may be gone, the ability to slot in (almost) any SATA hard drive is impossible to ignore. For users who frequently swap hard drives, need to load files to or from drives - or even need a way to quickly make copies of drives without having to crack open their case (via eSATA, mind you), a unit such as this is absolutely perfect. That said, let's take a look at the packaging.

Unlike the previous unit in this review, the xAGE does have a wider consumer appeal, and may just strike into the heart of your average geek - with that potential in mind, it appears the marketing team over at iStarUSA has gone and created a quite tasteful little package - wrapped in a black box with a picture of the drive's "installation" on the front, and a number of applications on the side, this unit would hold it's own admirably on a retail shelf, and considering the durability of the packaging, there's little reason why it shouldn't. Let's take a look at what comes in this box.


Profile Shot

"Installation"

Drives not Included.

Unassuming little fellow.

Giving the "enclosure" a quick once over, the feel of it immediately smacks of quality, despite it's diminutive ABS frame. Pushing back the spring loaded flap at the top, a bog standard SATA connector can be seen tucked away deep inside the unit, with no indications of exactly where those connectors go. Turning the unit around to it's rear, a (disappointingly included) punch-out for E-SATA, a USB connector, power button, and power jack can be seen. Swinging the unit around to the front, a blue LED lights right up when a drive is dropped in, only turning to a slightly purple hue when the drive is accessed - and though that "button" at the front does little more than turn the illumination into a ring, it does help with the overall aesthetics of the device. When installed, the drives feel secure, and the unit keeps it's footing, which is nice to prove my fear of it being aimlessly knocked over alleviated.  With that tour of the grounds taken care of, all that's left is to take it for a spin in HDTach to show off the limitations of the USB bus, and a conclusion surrounding these two products.


Hello down there!

Unlit button

Rear Panel

3.5" Drive Installed

2.5" Drive Installed

All Lit Up.

Performance and Conclusion:

Well, the notion that the USB2 bus limits hard drive performance is already well ingrained, and proved many times over, this run is simply a courtesy - to show that the device is capable of saturating the USB bus in the interest of providing the maximum data throughput for your drives.

Right, there we go. That graph above shows that the xAGE-N99-SAU/US is a competent and capable performer. Pair this with the great build quality, and incredible ease of use afforded by the T5F-SS, and you now have the option of operating two systems on one set of hardware, and doing so completely painlessly. After all, the former is completely transparent, and the latter installs without the need for drivers in everything above Windows 98SE.

Considering the simplicity of the setup, the ease of use, and the elegance of it all, iStarUSA has come up with a winning pair of products, items which I can see holding their use for many years to come. For this, I can easily recommend both to users who require the security and convenience afforded by quickly removing and replacing hard drives, or simply those who want to test out many different operating systems on their set of hardware. Good show iStarUSA!

<< Back to VH FrontPage >>

 

Got News? Send 'em in!

.


 

  Quiet Computer Fans
  Quiet CPU Coolers
  Quiet PC Power Supply
  Noctua Fans
  Noctua CPU Fans
  Quiet PC Fan
  Quiet CPU Fan
  Computer Sound Dampening
  PC Sound Proofing
  Noctua NH-U12P SE Intel Socket 1366 CPU Cooler
  Noctua 1366 CPU heatsink
  1366 CPU Heatsink
  Noctua NH-U12 DX Xeon CPU Heatsink
  Laptop Cooling Pad - Laptop Cooling
  Laptop Toys - Laptop Cooling
  Laptop Cooling Pad - Laptop Cooling
 
Acoustic PC: Quiet Computer Hardware & PC Soundproofing

 - Computer Laptops
 - Computer Power Supply
 - Data Recovery
 - Raid Data Recovery
 - Electronic Components from Made in China
 - Data Recovery Software
 - Data Recovery
 - Computer Forensics
 - RAID Data Recovery
 - Computer forensic
 - Shopbot Canada
 - Data Recovery Services
 - Computer Forensics
 - Data Recovery
 - Data Recovery
 
 
 
 

Copyright © 1999 - 2009 Virtual-Hideout LLC.
All other trademarks and copyrights on this site are property of their respective owners. All Rights Reserved.