|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Click here to join the VH Forums!
Introduction:
It's been a long time since there has been any innovation or even "change" to the infamous rounded IDE Cables we've all come to never live without. The time is now though that someone dare mess with something that just plain works. Is it in vein or is there actually room for improvement, short of custom making your own? Well A.C.Ryan thinks so and our buds over at Performance-PC's are stocked up on what could be called a "new" rounded IDE Cable to hit the market. It's being dubbed as the Roundcable2-FX series.
The Product: A quick glance at the product with a trained eye and you'll notice that the 2 IDE connections on one end of the cable are extremely close. Will this innovation bring an end to the big bulky "loop" of cable from dvd drive to dvd burner on your computer? In theory it appears to be a god send. In practice it has it weaknesses. Let's take a closer look at the product....
I think the pictures above are pretty self-explanatory. You see a couple different sizes and colors. Remember not all colors are UV reactive. In this case, silver and black are not UV reactive. Moving on... If I can draw your attention to the two upper pictures, you'll notice they're the same cable but differ slightly. The roundcable2-FX cables come "stock" as you see in the upper left picture. However if it's a tight squeeze between the two drives you're trying to connect (and it will be, if not impossible), then you can jerk and pull on the end connector to stretch out that tiny bit of ribbon cable overhang to gain a practically insignificant 1/4" maybe. I had to pull it out just to get close to connecting two drives so I'm not sure who has drives THAT close together, but mine weren't. Now drawing your attention to the upper bottom right picture (o0) you'll see a size comparison, with measurements, between the evil stock ribbon cables that come with most motherboards, a typical rounded cable, and the "new" roundcable2-FX cables. As you can see the connectors on the Roundcable2-FX series aren't just a little closer together.....they're VERY close together! Too close together perhaps? Read on...there's unfortunately more issues...
The pictures above show a disturbing occurrence that is the product of simply using the product. It's pretty evident that using just about any IDE cable you're going to have to bend the cables at least once, but more likely 2-3 times to get them into place in your system. These cables do not like to bend. They should in fact "flex" smoothly across the diameter of the cable as you position them into your case. Instead they bend, or KINK, into the desired shape! I noticed the second I removed them from their packaging that they felt "stiff". So of course the first thing you do is bend them. Well, it was like tearing off a turkey leg on thanksgiving. You could just feel the mesh inside crushing into itself. When I tried to re-straighten the cables there was obvious permanent damage to the inner mesh and I hadn't even USED the product yet! Pretty disheartening to say the least. The last picture above is the product of simply bending the product back and forth a few times. And I'm not talking completely bending and squishing the bend, I'm talking just bending the ends together each way. Something a typical IDE cable we've all come to know and love would have no problem with doing. Bottom Line: WAY TOO STIFF!... Moving on....
This next scenario is an interesting one. I'm currently between cases right now since I just bought a new X2 system, meaning I'm using the HSPC Tech Station as my main rig and test bench right now and I tell ya what, it's a good thing! Otherwise I would not have been able to connect this roundcable2-fx at all! Remember when I asked earlier if the connections were "too close?", well they are without a doubt too close together. I have a standard Pioneer slot-DVD drive and a new Sony 720-A DVD+RW in this setup. That's not a crazy setup and lots of you guys out there probably have the same drive setup. They're very popular choices in todays market. Well, the IDE ports on the two drives are not EXACTLY lined up vertically, therefore the Roundcable2-FX cable simply would not fit. Take a close look at the pictures above and notice the drives are staggered on the test bench. I could not physically line up the drives as they would be in a real case. Trying to flush the sides of the drives together was a lost cause, there simply was NOT enough distance between the IDE connections on the FX cable. Trying to flush the front of the drives was also an impossible mission because the slot load DVD drive was a good bit longer than the DVD-RW pictured below it. Once again, no where near enough cable. That is just totally unacceptable. I guess these are "use if you have the right drive setup" cables, and should subsequently say so on the packaging.
As you can see here, a typical dual hard drive setup is what these cables are ideally suited for, other than the cables stiffness. You'll pretty much have to pre-bend the cables to somewhere near your desired position before you install them. Conclusion: What an unforeseen ending to a highly anticipated product. I was quite anxious to get my hands on them thinking "now that's a great idea". Well, it IS a great idea, but badly executed. I simply can not recommend the Roundcable2-FX series at this point in time. Even if your drives DO match both depth and rear IDE port location it still comes down to that horribly stiff mesh that damages almost immediately. Softer mesh, better materials and an extra inch or two between the IDE connections and these would be a winner. Unfortunately right now though, they're just an "good idea gone bad". Pros:
Cons:
*Update 9-12-05* After this review posted I got an email from AC Ryan:
Now I don't mind companies making products and "experimenting", but I think that's called R&D and those products are not usually released to the public until they're correct and preferably without flaws. I think more companies need to take a little more time testing their products before they release them. With that said, I do appreciate AC Ryans attentiveness to the situation and more companies could take a lesson from them in that aspect anyway. As always, I will keep you guys informed. Until the new version is released, and tested, I stand by my thoughts in this review. It's really a great "idea" and I hope the wrongs are righted in the new version. Until then, wait for the new cables.
Got News? Send 'em in!
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
| |
|